0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Contact
The Pizza Mafia Grill Logo
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Contact
  • Order Online
Group Order Sign Up For Deals

The Pizza Mafia Grill Online Ordering Menu

1276 FAIRPORT RD
FAIRPORT, NY 14450
(585) 673-2020
11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Start your carryout or delivery order.
Check Availability

DINNERS

Italian Chili 
Mafia original.
$7.95
Parmesan Dinner 
Uncle Nicks Parm Dinner. Your choice of chicken or eggplant over pasta and topped with house made sauce .
$11.99+
Sunday Dinner 
Grampa Jims homemade sauce, meatballs & sausage. Served with garlic toast.
$11.99
Stuffed Shells Dinner 
Served with garlic toast.
$11.99
Fish Fry 
Beer battered and flash fried haddock, served with fries and coleslaw.
$14.99
Daily Soup 
Call restaurant for daily selection.
$4.99

SPECIALTY SANDWICHES

The Giambroni 
House-made marinara with your choice of seasoned or breaded chicken or eggplant.
$11.50+
Al Capone Sandwich 
House-made sausage, whipped ricotta, roasted peppers, and onions.
$12.50
The Big Chooch 
House-made meatballs, marinara, capicola, provolone, mozzarella, and red sauce.
$12.99
Luca Brasi Sandwich 
Marinated grilled steak, balsamic reduction, caramelized onions, mushrooms, tomato, and your choice of cheese.
$11.99
Carlo's Way 
Tuna salad, jalapenos, and Swiss cheese on a lightly toasted bun.
$9.50

SPECIALTY PIZZAS

Mangia! (Sheet) 
Picture bruschetta, but on a pizza. Garlic sauce, crispy prosciutto, mozzarella, basil, tomatoes, and balsamic reduction drizzle.
$41.50
Goodfellas (Sheet) 
Red sauce & garlic sauce mixed with whipped ricotta, Parmesan, and mozzarella cheese.
$38.50+
How You Doin (Sheet) 
Garlic sauce, whipped ricotta, tomato, and spinach.
$38.50
Bada-Bing (Sheet) 
Red sauce, house-made meatballs, sausage, whipped ricotta, banana peppers, caramelized onions, and mozzarella.
$41.00+
Bills Mafia (Sheet) 
House-made sweet buffalo sauce, chicken, crispy prosciutto, red onion, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, and ranch drizzle.
$39.00
Goodfellas (Large) 
Red sauce & garlic sauce mixed with whipped ricotta, Parmesan, and mozzarella cheese.
$20.00
Mangia! Pizza (Large) 
Picture bruschetta, but on a pizza. Garlic sauce, crispy prosciutto, mozzarella, basil, tomatoes, and balsamic reduction drizzle.
$21.50
How You Doin Pizza (Large) 
Garlic sauce, whipped ricotta, tomato, and spinach.
$19.75
Bills Mafia Pizza (Large) 
House-made sweet buffalo sauce, chicken, crispy prosciutto, red onion, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, and ranch drizzle.
$20.50
Bada-Bing (Large) 
Red sauce, house-made meatballs, sausage, whipped ricotta, banana peppers, caramelized onions, and mozzarella.
$21.50+
Bills Mafia Pizza (Medium) 
House-made sweet buffalo sauce, chicken, crispy prosciutto, red onion, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, and ranch drizzle.
$15.00
How You Doin Pizza (Medium) 
Garlic sauce, whipped ricotta, tomato, and spinach.
$15.75
Mangia! Pizza (Medium) 
Picture bruschetta, but on a pizza. Garlic sauce, crispy prosciutto, mozzarella, basil, tomatoes, and balsamic reduction drizzle.
$17.00
Goodfellas (Medium) 
Red sauce & garlic sauce mixed with whipped ricotta, Parmesan, and mozzarella cheese.
$15.50+
Bada-Bing (Medium) 
Red sauce, house-made meatballs, sausage, whipped ricotta, banana peppers, caramelized onions, and mozzarella.
$16.50+
Bada-Bing (Small) 
Red sauce, house-made meatballs, sausage, whipped ricotta, banana peppers, caramelized onions, and mozzarella.
$13.75+
Goodfellas (Small) 
Red sauce & garlic sauce mixed with whipped ricotta, Parmesan, and mozzarella cheese.
$12.00+
How You Doin (Small) 
Garlic sauce, whipped ricotta, tomato, and spinach.
$11.75
Bills Mafia Pizza (Small) 
House-made sweet buffalo sauce, chicken, crispy prosciutto, red onion, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, and ranch drizzle.
$11.75
Mangia! Pizza (Small) 
Picture bruschetta, but on a pizza. Garlic sauce, crispy prosciutto, mozzarella, basil, tomatoes, and balsamic reduction drizzle.
$12.50+
Forget-About-It Calzone 
A calzone with red or white garlic sauce.
$14.00

SOMETHING SWEET

Mini Cannolis 
$5.99
Cookies 
$2.50
Fried Dough 
$5.00
Dippin Dots 
$3.50

PIZZA

Small Pizza 
$9.00+
Medium Pizza 
$12.50+
Large Pizza 
$17.00+
Sheet Pizza 
$35.50+

FRIED GOODS

Mozzarella Sticks 
$6.50
French Fries 
$4.00
Chicken Fingers 
$10.00+

SLICES

Cheese Slice 
$3.50

DRINKS

Fizz 
$2.00
Fountain Drink 
$3.00
Bottled Drink 
$3.00
Water 
$2.00
Gatorade 
$3.00

SALADS

House Salad 
Tomatoes, red onions, artichokes, light Parmesan, and light balsamic vinaigrette.
$8.99
Caesar Salad 
Red onions, croutons, cannellini beans, and Caesar dressing.
$9.99
Buffa-love 
Healthy game-day option. Shredded chicken with buffalo sauce, tomatoes, red onion, and bleu cheese.
$12.00
Off The Boat 
A light pour of our house made sauce over a giant meatball with fresh greens and ricotta on the side.
$13.00

WINGS

Jumbo Wings (10) 
$14.49+
Boneless Wings (10) 
$10.00+

SIDE SAUCES

Side of Sauce 
$0.75
Side of Bleu Cheese 
$0.75
Side of Ranch 
$0.75
Side BBQ Sauce 
$0.75
Meatball 
$4.00

Coupons

Weekend Family Special 
$27.49
Lunch Special 
$9.99

Bread

Fresh Bread 
$2.00
Pizza Dough 
$4.50
Your cart is empty.
  • Visit our Facebook
Powered by Menufy © 2022
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.